Intrepid Slate writer Emily Yoffe just did two weeks in a day care center to see if she could stand up to the punishment of being a childcare worker. Then she discussed her experience here.
I started writing a post about this, and before I knew it, that post was longer than any post has ever been in the history of blogging. So I broke it up into four chunks, most of which consider the vexed intersection of "meniality" and childcare.
It seems to be taken for granted that childcare is "low-level" work. Here's how the thinking goes: You don't need an engineering degree to change a diaper, or a psychology degree to comfort a crying toddler (although it's entirely possible you might need a psychology degree to comfort a crying toddler well, i.e. with a real understanding of the often not-at-all-obvious aspects of his developmental stage), so it must be a waste of time for anyone with brains. (This is the whole "you're wasting your education" meme.)
Therefore, proceeds this shining piece of "logic," childcare should be fobbed off on others (who we CLAIM deserve respect, but who somehow, oh-so-curiously, do not feel like they actually get any from us) while we go off and "use our minds."
Ahem.
If you go eye-to-eye with a baby, with its curiosity, its delight, its striving, and you still think it's the functional equivalent of a vegetative nursing home patient (only easier to put in the stroller) (and by no means am I suggesting that taking care of a vegetative nursing home patient does not require brains or insight--I'm talking metaphor here)...then you better take another look at who's "low-level." Hint: It just might be you.
(DISCLAIMER: The above DOES NOT MEAN I think everyone should stay at home with their babies. Obviously, it is not the right choice for everyone. It is not even, unfortunately, a possible choice for everyone, whether they want it to be or not. Nor do I think taking care of a baby or small child is fun and games. It's not. But: I think people who see it as "menial"--see below--have missed the point so badly that they should look into repeating sixth grade. Onward:)
#
In that Yoffe discussion, scroll down to the comment from "Maryland," the self-described mother of a four-month-old.
Maryland announces her discovery that "the bulk of the tasks involved in caring for him are entirely menial, requiring not one jot of education or training, just common sense, endurance and love."
As I'm sure is already abundantly clear, I am never in a forgiving mood for comments like this.
Maryland, here's the deal:
1) That statement makes you come off as uninformed. Seriously.
Do you know anything about babies' brains?
Do you realize that, every time you speak to your baby, his brain is picking out patterns in your speech that will help him learn language?
That every time you engage his eyes, you're pre-socializing him and forging his understanding of relationships?
That every time you answer his cries, you're teaching him how to trust the world?
That every time you cuddle him and tell him you love him, you're increasing the love in his own heart?
That every time you take that extra minute to grin with him, to encourage his delight, you're teaching him how to be happy?
That every time he waves his little arms, he's strengthening himself and increasing his motor control?
That every time he touches or grips or tastes something, he's doing science?
Your baby's existence is one of maximum stakes and heroic, determined effort. Just because he does most of it while gurgling doesn't mean it isn't serious. A lot of stuff is happening in your baby's mind, body and emotions every second. Impressions are being formed that will never be un-formed. Babies imprint everything, whether you're aware of it or not.
What you do for your son may well be simple. But it is by no means simplistic. If you knew the significance of your interactions with him, I bet you wouldn't find them so "menial."
2) And even if they were...
'JUST common sense, endurance and love'? JUST!? JUST!?!!
Fortunately, Emily Yoffe is equal to the challenge Maryland presents.
In her genteel, ladylike reply to Maryland, Yoffe says:
"Common sense, endurance and love are [indeed] the hallmark qualities of a good day care worker. And you're right, those aren't necessarily the qualities of highly educated professionals."
HA! Thank you, Emily.
Although, I will say, they are the qualities of good highly educated professionals.
More "meniality" tomorrow. Or maybe the day after. Soon.